Advertisement
www.hindu.com/2009/08/30/...53760100.htm
ISRO loses radio contact with Chandrayaan-1
T.S. Subramanian
India’s first moon mission cut short; a lot of data gained
CHENNAI: In a major blow to India’s maiden mission to the moon, the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) abruptly lost contact with Chandrayaan-1 at 01.30 a.m. on Saturday. This means no command can be given to the spacecraft and no data, including images of the moon’s surface, are being received from it.
The Chandrayaan-1 mission has come to an end in ten months instead of its slated life of two years.
“We are not able to give commands to the spacecraft,” S. Satish, Director, Publications and Public Relations Department of ISRO, told The Hindu. “We are not able to establish communication with it, with the result that we do not know what is happening.”
The Indian Deep Space Network (IDSN) at Byalalu village, near Bangalore, received data from Chandrayaan-1 till an hour before radio contact was lost. The IDSN, with its huge antennae with diameters of 32 metres and 18 metres, is the hub of communications from the ground with the spacecraft. It is from Byalalu that commands were radioed to the spacecraft to perform various manoeuvres. Images from Chandrayaan-1 were also received here.
India’s first spacecraft to the moon was launched on October 22, 2008 from Sriharikota. An ISRO press release noted on Saturday that the spacecraft had completed 312 days in orbit, making more than 3,400 orbits around the moon. It provided a large amount of data from its sophisticated instruments such as the Terrain Mapping Camera, the Hyper-Spectral Imager, the Moon Mineralogy Mapper and so on. ISRO claimed that the mission had met most of its scientific objectives.
Chandrayaan-1 sent back more than 70,000 images of the lunar surface, which provided breathtaking views of lunar mountains and craters, especially craters in the permanently shadowed areas of the moon’s polar region. It also collected data on the chemical and mineral content of the moon’s soil.
But the troubles that have cut short the life of the moon mission began in November itself when the spacecraft’s power subsystems started failing one by one. In April, the mission went into a crisis, with the primary star-sensor and the backup star-sensor failing. But top ISRO officials appeared keen to play down the setbacks, with a May 20 press release making no mention of the failure of the star-sensors and the power units.
Asked what could have gone wrong with the spacecraft, Mr. Satish said: “Some electronic sub-system could have malfunctioned. We are looking at the telemetry data and trying to find out what is the problem. Using the telemetry data [received till contact with the spacecraft was lost], the health of the spacecraft is being analysed. It is expected to throw light on the problem noticed. ISRO’s stations are trying to revive the spacecraft.”
Asked whether Chadrayaan-1 was drifting away from its orbit, Mr. Satish said it was “definitely in orbit.” However, if the present situation continued, the orbit could be disrupted.
ISRO experts explained that all communication with Chandrayaan-1 and the receipt of data from it were handled through on-board electronic systems. “If radio contact with Chandrayaan is suddenly lost,” a top expert pointed out, “only electronic systems on the spacecraft could have failed. Otherwise, this could not have happened. From the symptoms, it looks as if the electronics failed.”
A Polar Satellite Launch Vehicle (PSLV) of ISRO put Chandrayaan-1 in its initial orbit. The spacecraft carried 11 instruments on board. One of them named the Moon Impact Probe (MIP) “impacted” on the lunar surface on November 14, 2008, signalling India’s success in reaching the moon.
ISRO loses radio contact with Chandrayaan-1
T.S. Subramanian
India’s first moon mission cut short; a lot of data gained
CHENNAI: In a major blow to India’s maiden mission to the moon, the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) abruptly lost contact with Chandrayaan-1 at 01.30 a.m. on Saturday. This means no command can be given to the spacecraft and no data, including images of the moon’s surface, are being received from it.
The Chandrayaan-1 mission has come to an end in ten months instead of its slated life of two years.
“We are not able to give commands to the spacecraft,” S. Satish, Director, Publications and Public Relations Department of ISRO, told The Hindu. “We are not able to establish communication with it, with the result that we do not know what is happening.”
The Indian Deep Space Network (IDSN) at Byalalu village, near Bangalore, received data from Chandrayaan-1 till an hour before radio contact was lost. The IDSN, with its huge antennae with diameters of 32 metres and 18 metres, is the hub of communications from the ground with the spacecraft. It is from Byalalu that commands were radioed to the spacecraft to perform various manoeuvres. Images from Chandrayaan-1 were also received here.
India’s first spacecraft to the moon was launched on October 22, 2008 from Sriharikota. An ISRO press release noted on Saturday that the spacecraft had completed 312 days in orbit, making more than 3,400 orbits around the moon. It provided a large amount of data from its sophisticated instruments such as the Terrain Mapping Camera, the Hyper-Spectral Imager, the Moon Mineralogy Mapper and so on. ISRO claimed that the mission had met most of its scientific objectives.
Chandrayaan-1 sent back more than 70,000 images of the lunar surface, which provided breathtaking views of lunar mountains and craters, especially craters in the permanently shadowed areas of the moon’s polar region. It also collected data on the chemical and mineral content of the moon’s soil.
But the troubles that have cut short the life of the moon mission began in November itself when the spacecraft’s power subsystems started failing one by one. In April, the mission went into a crisis, with the primary star-sensor and the backup star-sensor failing. But top ISRO officials appeared keen to play down the setbacks, with a May 20 press release making no mention of the failure of the star-sensors and the power units.
Asked what could have gone wrong with the spacecraft, Mr. Satish said: “Some electronic sub-system could have malfunctioned. We are looking at the telemetry data and trying to find out what is the problem. Using the telemetry data [received till contact with the spacecraft was lost], the health of the spacecraft is being analysed. It is expected to throw light on the problem noticed. ISRO’s stations are trying to revive the spacecraft.”
Asked whether Chadrayaan-1 was drifting away from its orbit, Mr. Satish said it was “definitely in orbit.” However, if the present situation continued, the orbit could be disrupted.
ISRO experts explained that all communication with Chandrayaan-1 and the receipt of data from it were handled through on-board electronic systems. “If radio contact with Chandrayaan is suddenly lost,” a top expert pointed out, “only electronic systems on the spacecraft could have failed. Otherwise, this could not have happened. From the symptoms, it looks as if the electronics failed.”
A Polar Satellite Launch Vehicle (PSLV) of ISRO put Chandrayaan-1 in its initial orbit. The spacecraft carried 11 instruments on board. One of them named the Moon Impact Probe (MIP) “impacted” on the lunar surface on November 14, 2008, signalling India’s success in reaching the moon.
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: ISRO loses radio contact with Chandrayaan-1
Sun, August 30, 2009 - 6:39 AMAlmost sounds like they used off-the-shelf electronics (which are not space-hardened and thus very sensitive to cosmic rays). -
-
Re: ISRO loses radio contact with Chandrayaan-1
Sun, August 30, 2009 - 11:09 AM>"off-the-shelf electronics"<
Kind of wonder what that means today vs several years ago. Companies like SpaceDev have been making systems for spacecraft for a while. And off the shelf systems can come with some shielding...at least they do with for military. Or they can have housings with shielding.
Anyhow, shielding could very well be the issue. They seem to have made their major goals and might have leverage some risk to save on weight and time. Or their ground testing system for shielding might not be as good as they thought. Not to mention that the solar storm weather and the cosmic ray weather might be acting up enough to kill the craft off. -
-
Re: ISRO loses radio contact with Chandrayaan-1
Sun, August 30, 2009 - 2:08 PMWhen I think off-the-shelf, I'm thinking what one can buy at Fry's. All it takes to destroy most consumer electronics is one high energy (>1 MeV) heavy nuclei (like iron) through a critical component (say the CPU). Fortunately, those are rare at sea level. Even with shielding, most space craft have multiple redundancy.
Of course, a well placed micrometeorite could have done it in as well. So who knows what really happened. -
-
Re: ISRO loses radio contact with Chandrayaan-1
Sun, August 30, 2009 - 4:01 PM>"When I think off-the-shelf, I'm thinking what one can buy at Fry's"<
Well, yes sort of....everything on a spacecraft has to be rack based. Your run of the mill pc boxes won't work. But I guess they get a vendor who can order the stuff from the manufacturer. And then the housing of the space craft is where the shielding would be for a basic set up.
Think a micro meteorite would cause a sudden failure. Looks like whats been happening here is a systematic failure over time. That would be synonymous with a capacitance build up or a charge build up that would just freeze the electronics. Which could be caused by radiation. -
-
Re: ISRO loses radio contact with Chandrayaan-1
Sun, August 30, 2009 - 8:57 PMSince I've worked on the EUVE trying to model system failures, I can tell you a series of failures need not be related. Although this was the final failure in a series of failures, it is still possible (though unlikely) that a micrometeorite caused them all (damage to one systems leading to a cascading short). More likely would be a series of unrelated failures, then a major failure caused be a micrometeorite (a larger one, say rice sized instead of sand sized).
Of course, the simplest explanation is purely electronic but we will never know unless it is recovered. -
-
Re: ISRO loses radio contact with Chandrayaan-1
Mon, August 31, 2009 - 3:51 AM>"I can tell you a series of failures need not be related."<
Absolutely. -
-
Re: ISRO loses radio contact with Chandrayaan-1
Mon, August 31, 2009 - 11:17 AMRegardless of the cause, it is a unfortunate loss... -
-
Re: ISRO loses radio contact with Chandrayaan-1
Mon, August 31, 2009 - 11:52 AMYes, its a loss, but its a great success for India to have even sent and gathered the data they did gather. They manage to operate their first non-earth unmanned spacecraft. Which is a remarkable achievement seeing that only a few years ago they were getting their rocket up and running. -
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
Re: ISRO loses radio contact with Chandrayaan-1
Mon, August 31, 2009 - 8:28 PM70,000 images were sent back during over 3,400 orbits. That is pretty good, and its life span was only supposed to be 2 years long anyway. So it's not a total loss.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Re: ISRO loses radio contact with Chandrayaan-1
Mon, August 31, 2009 - 11:55 PMVideo (23 minutes 32 seconds): www.youtube.com/watch
Al Jazeera English - Inside Story - India's moon mission - 31 August 09
Ten months after it was launched, India's moon mission came to an abrupt end after scientists lost communication with the orbiting spacecraft "Chandrayaan I". Inside Story discusses the achievements and the future of space exploration.